A Film Essay on “4 Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days” which analyses the Subjection and Individual Freedom of Gabita and Otilia

A 1,290word film essay which analyzed the subjection and individual freedom of the female characters in the film "4 Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days." The essay was part of a Philosophy course which was instructed by Professor Janna Van Grunsven

Please download to get full document.

View again

of 5
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.


Publish on:

Views: 4 | Pages: 5

Extension: PDF | Download: 0

  Mr. Matthew S. Shepler Professor Janna Van GrunsvenPHIL 100010 May 2015A !l" #ssay on $% Months& ' (ee)s& an* 2 +ays, wh!-h analyses the Su/e-t!on an* In*!v!*ualree*o" of Ga!ta an* t!l!a Introduction  In h!s ph!losoph!-al tet The Subjection of Women, John Stuart M!ll arues that the "oral!ty of /ust!-e "ust not only !n-lu*e e3ual!ty a"on the sees& ut also sy"pathy an* fa"!lystru-ture. (hen apply!n th!s ph!losoph!-al thouht to the f!l"& $% Months& ' (ee)s& an* 2 +ays&, we -an see that Ga!ta an* t!l!a l!ve !n a re!on of the worl* where "oral!ty rest "ore alon the l!nes of an $ol!at!on to su"!t to power, rather than a r!ht 4M!ll& %6. 7here& so"e wo"en "ay e !nfluen-e* to su/e-t the"selves to super!or "ales who are ev!l !n -hara-ter  e-ause of !ne3ual!ty a"on the sees wh!-h !s -o""on !n pla-es l!)e 8o"an!a. 7he su/e-t!on of Ga!ta an* t!l!a le* to an un/ust l!fe. Ma!nly& e-ause of the fa-t that Mr. 9ee persua*e* Ga!ta to un*ero an !lleal la-):"ar)et aort!on. #ven thouh the !lleal "e*!-al pro-e*ure !nvolve* ser!ous r!s)s;r!s)s that relate* to health an* law;Ga!ta st!ll *e-!*e* to su/e-t herself to Mr. 9ee. (!th that !n "!n*& th!s paper see)s to not only analy<e the su/e-t!on of wo"en w!th!n 8o"an!a& ut also answer the follow!n 3uest!on= $*oes f!l" e*u-ate people aout ph!losoph!-al theor!es "ore than tet>, Argumentative  7h!s aru"ent -ontra*!-ts the fa-t that Ga!ta?s su/e-t!on was ol!ate* y support!n the thouht that Ga!ta eer-!se* her r!ht to su/e-t to Mr. 9ee. In fa-t& the su/e-t!on of Ga!ta "ay have een !nfluen-e* y t!l!a when she ean to epla!n that Mr. 9ee was a well:)nown "e*!-al pra-t!-!an who spe-!al!<e* !n aort!ons. Mr. 9ee wasn?t /ust a super!or when -o"pare* to Ga!ta& ut "ay have also een per-e!ve* as an e*u-ate* person who atta!ne*  Shepler, Page 2  profess!onal )nowle*e that relate* to the f!el* of "e*!-al pra-t!-e. Mr. 9ee ean to epla!n toGa!ta that su/e-t!n to the aort!on woul* e alr!ht e-ause he woul* e the one who woul*  e at r!s) w!th the law. After Ga!ta prepare* for the !lleal pro-e*ure& Mr. 9ee ean pro!n Ga!ta for pr!vate !nfor"at!on that relate* to the *urat!on of t!"e !n:etween per!o*s. Ga!ta then prov!*e* the !nfor"at!on to Mr. 9ee& as he then a*v!se* youn Ga!ta to prepare for the "e*!-al pro-e*ure. The Subjection of Gabita  7he su/e-t!on of Ga!ta was !nfluen-e* y the !ne3ual!ty of sees an* reat r!s)s to Ga!ta an* t!l!a wh!-h "ay have en*anere* the!r free*o"& as well as Ga!ta?s health. Ga!ta epla!ne* that she *!*n?t have the *es!re to pro-ee* w!th an !lleal "e*!-al pro-e*ure;wh!-h& therefore& *!*n?t -reate the "etaphor!-al "ot!on to su/e-t to the super!or f!ure who was o!n to -on*u-t an !lleal aort!on to her o*y. Ga!ta?s la-) of *es!re to have the !lleal aort!on -ause* a nervous e"ot!on *ur!n her su/e-t!on. Mr. 9ee -o"pla!ne* when Ga!ta an* t!l!a -oul*n?t prov!*e enouh "oney to pay for the aort!on. In fa-t& Mr. 9ee ean epress!n aner wh!-h !n-rease* h!s super!or role. Mr. 9ee epla!ne* to Ga!ta an* t!lla that they were the one?s see)!n the !lleal aort!on. Ga!ta then showe* "ore !ntense -hara-ter!st!-s of !nfer!orness& an* even su/e-te* herself further. Ga!ta?s su/e-t!on was natural to her !nfer!or -hara-ter. In fa-t& the "ore Ga!ta su/e-te*& the "ore Mr. 9ee woul* "a)e her feel l!)e an !nfer!or;"a!nly& y epla!n!n reater r!s)s w!th the law wh!-h persua*e* Ga!ta an* t!lla to th!n) that they were the ones to la"e for the !lleal a-t!v!ty. 7hereafter& Ga!ta staye* !n the roo" alone to re:-ooperate fro" the !lleal aort!on. The Subjection of Otilia  Shepler, Page 3  A*! showe* pro"!se of treat!n t!l!a l!)e an e3ual e-ause of the fa-t that he was "ore oo* !n -hara-ter when -o"pare* to the ev!l -hara-ter of Mr. 9ee. 7h!s thouht was supporte*  y fa-t that A*! epla!ne* to t!l!a that h!s solut!on woul* have een "arr!ae. t!l!a su/e-te* herself "ore to Ga!ta than she *!* to A*!& ut proaly e-ause !t e-a"e her ol!at!on. 7o epla!n& t!l!a "a*e proress towar* etter e3ual!ty when she travele* a-) to Ga!ta?s hotel roo" an* *!spose* of a *ea* -h!l*?s -orpse;t!l!a?s -r!"e was her !nvolve"ent w!th the "ur*er of an unorn -h!l*. Here& the $v!-e of @eausesa!s 8o"an!an *!-tor!al state, 4Grunsven6 was ea"ple* when analy<!n t!l!a?s !nvolve"ent w!th the "ur*er an* *!sposal of an unorn -h!l*. After hav!n lun-h at a pul!- -af& Ga!ta as)e* t!l!a what she *!* w!th the *ea* -orpse. or th!s reason& t!l!a proaly l!ve* w!th a lot of nervous e"ot!ons later her l!fe when refle-t!n  a-) to e!n asso-!ate* w!th Mr. 9ee& an* re-olle-t!n the pro!n of Ga!ta?s pr!vate !nfor"at!on. Conclusion  #ven thouh the r!s)s that relate* to !lleal "e*!-al pra-t!-e woul* have "a*e Ga!ta Mr.9ee?s ol!at!on& Ga!ta epresse* e"ot!ons that supporte* the !*ea that she felt ol!ate* to su/e-t to the !lleal aort!on. 7o support th!s -la!"& Ga!ta epresse* a la-) of *es!re for the !lleal aort!on wh!-h prevente* her "etaphor!-al "ot!on of su/e-t!on to Mr. 9ee?s !lleal "e*!-al pra-t!-e. After t!l!a an* Mr. 9ee use* "oney& r!s)s& an* super!orness to help  persua*e Ga!ta to su/e-t& Ga!ta f!nally su/e-te* to the !lleal "e*!-al pra-t!-e of Mr. 9ee. 7he !lleal la-):"ar)et s-he"e pose* reat threats to the!r free*o"& health& an* even supporte* an !ne3ual!ty of sees w!th!n the 8o"an!an re!on. #ven thouh th!s was the -ase& Ga!ta was ale to preserve her future y restr!-t!n herself fro" the r!ht to !ve !rth to her own -h!l*. In other wor*s& she e-a"e ol!ate* to fulf!ll an !lleal -ovenant w!th Mr. 9ee.  Shepler, Page 4  #ven thouh part of Ga!ta?s su/e-t!on was !nfluen-e* y t!l!a& !n a pla-e l!)e 8o"an!a& so"et!"es a wo"an "ay nee* to su/e-t herself to another wo"an to prote-t her fro" *anerous r!s)s;r!s)s that "ay e for-e* unto the wo"an fro" a super!or "ale who *on?t  per-e!ve h!s !nfer!ors as an ol!at!on. 7he -hara-ter of the "ale;e!ther oo* or ev!l;"ay also have an !nfluen-e on the su/e-t!on of a wo"an. Super!or "ales who !nha!t the re!on of 8o"an!a "ay use the law to persua*e wo"en that "ales are the super!or e!n wh!-h -ont!nues to !nfluen-e the!r su/e-t!on towar* a $v!-e of @eausesa!s 8o"an!an *!-tor!al state, 4Grunsven6. 7o prov!*e "ore support to th!s -la!"& t!l!a?s su/e-t!on for-e* her to *!spose of a *ea* -h!l*?s -orpse so that she -oul* save her own free*o";t!l!a?s -r!"e was her !nvolve"ent w!th the "ur*er& an* hen the *!sposal of a *ea* -h!l*B 7he *ar) l!ht!n an* so-!al surroun*!n of the alley helpe* *!splay the se-re-y an* r!s)s that was !nvolve* w!th *!spos!n the *ea* -h!l*?s -orpse. Also& the f!l" *e"onstrate* Ga!ta?s la-) of *es!re an* "etaphor!-al "ot!on to su/e-t when she was hes!tant an* showe* nervous e"ot!ons to Mr. 9ee. 7o -o"e to a -on-lus!on& !n an env!ron"ent that supports !ne3ual!ty a"on the sees& Ga!ta an* t!l!a turne* away fro" the *!re-t!on of fa"!ly stru-ture& as Ga!ta  e-a"e ol!ate* to su/e-t to a "ale who pose* to e ev!l !n -hara-ter. 7o epla!n "ore& Ga!ta aorte* her -h!l*& as t!l!a *eparte* fro" A*! who !nv!te* her !nto h!s fa"!ly an* even "ent!one* "arr!ae. 7houh& !n rear*s to -o"par!n the learn!n out-o"e fro" ph!losoph!-al tets an* f!l"s& th!s essay shows that tets "ay e*u-ate people "ore on ph!losoph!-al theor!es&  ut f!l" "ay help a stu*ent atta!n a further un*erstan*!n than he or she -o"prehen*s fro" stu*y!n a ph!losoph!-al tet.8esour-es  Shepler, Page 5 4 Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days. +!r. @hr!st!an Mun!u. Perf. le Mutu& M!haela Poenaru& +ana 9unes-u& @hr!st!nel S!rl!& Ph!ll!p Avr!l& Ale 7eo*ores-u. I@ !l"s& 200C. +v*.Grunsven& Janna Van. $top!- of f!l" essay., Messae to Matthew Shepler. 0' May 2015. #:"a!l.M!ll& John Stuart. The Subjection of Women. In*!anapol!s= Ha-)ett Pul!sh!n @o"pany& 1DEE. Pr!nt.
Related Search
Similar documents
View more...
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks